Text size
  • Small
  • Medium
  • Large
Contrast
  • Standard
  • Blue text on blue
  • High contrast (Yellow text on black)
  • Blue text on beige

The EU part 2 : Co-operation is not Surrender

We have a lot of problems in the UK, and the 'Alf Garnett mentality' offers us no solutions. It is unrealistic to suggest that the UK can be totally independent. For instance, we have to borrow money, and our ability to pay it back has to be judged internationally. Our failure to manage our economy properly is now likely to result in our credit rating being lowered from the AAA standard.

We are dependent upon imports, having unwisely de-industrialised in the 1980s. We are dependent, for instance, on Russian gas supplies and we import some nuclear power from France. We are generally bound by NATO and UN rulings for any military interventions, and we are very unwise if we disregard such rulings.

Just returning to EU Technological directives for one moment (covered in the last post), if you look at the EU Software Patents bill, there were obviously a lot of pros and cons surrounding Patenting. For instance, a lot of people felt that such a bill would disadvantage small independent contractors. However, doesn't the defeat in 2005 of the directive, disprove the notion that the EU Parliament can only 'rubber stamp' EU legislation? The vote to scrap the bill was passed by a margin of 648 votes to 14, with 18 abstentions.

Anyway, let's look at the single market for employment in Europe. One solution to our problems is language education. There may not be sufficient jobs in the UK in the future and it makes sense to have as an option the possibility of working in Europe. However, due to our lack of ability at languages, many of us lack the confidence to work in Europe, and that is part of the reason for our widespread hostility to the European project. It is obviously different for Europeans who think nothing of commuting into another country to work. Borders with many European countries are not as significant (and have, of course, been breached many times historically). Europeans are brought up in multi-lingual environments and are very often multi-lingual. We are an island race, and most of us grew up isolated from other languages. One thing the Government could do to improve this is to have a substantial initiative to improve foreign language competency. No more introductory classes for a few weeks, this time it needs to be a substantial 4-year evening course. Each year you would pay the fees (e.g. £150), but upon successful completion, the Government would pay you back the 4 years fees plus a £150 bonus. That would be £750.

One language people could consider learning, particularly in the business community, is German. The German speaking world is the largest linguistic community in the EU. Of course, the favourite Cliché is that everyone in Europe speaks English, so we needn't bother. That may apply when you are on holiday, but if you want to work for a substantial period of time in Europe, you do need to get some basic language skills. You will never understand much about what is happening around you unless you learn the native language.

How good are English skills in the UK?

Language competency is a sensitive issue in the UK. Many people in the UK are not very competent at their own language. If we continue to refuse to engage with Europe, there is a danger of England becoming a country with an uncommunicative underclass. Take, for example, Italy. They once spoke Latin, and that has formed the basis for languages throughout the world. In Roman times you would have had an advantage if you spoke Latin and you could have travelled confidently to almost anywhere in the Roman Empire and be understood. The Latin language was rapidly accepted by others, and evolved into different, newer languages such as Spanish. What may happen, if we are not careful, is that although we were the ones who originally spoke English, many of the heavier accents within the UK may be come indecipherable outside this country and become a major barrier to employment in Europe and even in the UK. That will add to the frustration of some UK residents when they perhaps try and work in Europe, but are told that no-one can understand them and they are being sent home. Certainly, the 'perfect' European English spoken by citizens in countries such as the Netherlands, is highly impressive and has a sharpness and clarity that puts some of our lazy 'Vicky Pollard' accents to shame. Let's put language skills, particularly English, at the top of the agenda in schools.

As far as IT contract working in Europe is concerned, it is usually necessary to work through umbrella companies. The freelance working model does not seem to be as big in Europe, but then the Recruitment Agency malaise of the UK is not as big either. For instance, in Luxembourg, until fairly recently, the government employment service, ADEM ( Administration de l'Emploi), was the only legally authorised recruitment agency. The growth in this sector is probably a sad reflection on the values we have in the UK in relation to work.We are all being made unnecessarily more expensive to employ by the margins that Agents take. Can we look at some legislation to deal with that? The easier we can make working in the EU the better, through the harmonising of healthcare and taxation and the recognition of qualifications.

The Government has destroyed our jobs, so let's start looking for jobs abroad, many of which you will notice have a specification in a foreign language. If you're the last person to leave, please turn out the lights.

Say what you like about the EU. There are no Lords in the EU Parliament. There are just ordinary people. There's no farcically dressed Speaker's entourages, no 'Black Rod', no 19th century Gentlemen's club rules. The EU parliament has never sent anyone to their deaths to fight in an illegal conflict. It has its faults, but it is a modern parliament, which is looking forward. Co-operation is not surrender.

Comments (6)

Leave Comment
  • 1
    Alex R wrote on 2nd Jun 2009

    Another Pro EU blog: Nothing to do with 6th is it by chance.

    Report Comment

  • 2
    ChrisW wrote on 2nd Jun 2009

    Another fine post, Tim, (are you planning to head abroad soon?) although I think you are slightly too optimistic about the chances of British IT workers finding jobs in Europe right now: Germany is also suffering a significant slowdown, for example. Also, Germany in particular has imported significant numbers of skilled IT workers from the EU countries of the former Eastern bloc in recent years, so their demand for Brits is lower than it once was. It is also worth recognising that some countries, such as Germany, may require some evidence of professional qualifications if you want to be recognised as a professional IT freelancer for tax/ employment purposes, which is not unreasonable but may involve extra paperwork, although this will depend on the employer and perhaps also on the local tax office. The UK limited company approach to contracting is not permitted in Germany, and your accountant (Steuerberater) is legally obliged to tell the tax authorities if you try to exploit any of the dodgy tax evasion schemes promoted by some agencies. So pay your slightly higher taxes, and then enjoy a vastly higher pension entitlement (or unemployment benefit if you need it) than you could ever hope to secure through state provision in the UK. ...... As for languages, you are right about the problems Brits have in communicating to non-native speakers of English: too many of us are no longer capable of speaking any kind of "standard" grammatical English, and as determined monoglots we are ignorant of how hard it can be for others to understand our own casual speech. But if you'd ever tried to speak standard German with a Swiss farmer whose first language is the German equivalent of Chaucer's English, you'd get the point very quickly: having access to a standard variety of the language helps everybody to communicate more easily, whatever their native language/dialect/accent. ...... As for which European language to learn, I applaud your enthusiasm for German. which I share, but schools have been dropping German in favour of Spanish for years, so German language skills are likely to become even rarer in the UK in future. Slavonic languages such as Russian or Polish, or a non-European language like Chinese, might be interesting alternatives, but these languages are seen as "hard" and there is a chronic shortage of teachers in these languages. ..... Meanwhile, of all the ways to learn languages, 4 years of weekly evening classes is probably the worst approach: it is almost impossible to maintain motivation for such a long period when you are making miniscule progress every week/ month. It is far better to try a short period of intensive study together with, or followed by, a longer period of regular exposure to the language. Residential courses are ideal e.g. the Open University runs a French summer school, while the Institut Francais or Goethe Institut can advise on residential courses in French and German. Or you can look for intensive evening/ weekend courses e.g. I went from total beginner to roughly GCSE level in Spanish in 4 weeks with 20 x 3 hour sessions and an excellent Spanish teacher (in Germany). Of course, as a language nerd, I love learning languages for their own sake, but for those who are less enthusiastic, it's always worth remembering former German Chancellor Willy Brandt's remark that "If I wish to sell to you I will speak English, but if you wish to sell to me dann müssen Sie Deutsch sprechen". So now that I'm trying to sell my rapidly aging IT skills in Germany/ Switzerland these days, dann werde ich auch Deutsch sprechen!

    Report Comment

  • 3
    Roger Smith wrote on 3rd Jun 2009

    "Cooperation is not surrender". That's what the mouse thought when it agreed to cooperate with the rattlesnake. Cooperation requires good faith on both sides. Time and again the UK has had its agreements to red line issues undermined or just swept away. NATO is not an EU institution; rather the EU is setting up its own defence arrangements to drive a wedge between the UK and its North American allies. The resulting impact on defence procurement has cost British lives through the purchase of costly and unsuitable equipment. Never mind that the Lisbon Treaty has not yet been ratified, the EU is acting as if it were. UK voters were denied the promised referendum, so the EU has no popular mandate to impose its law on us. Cooperation, yes. Subjugation, no thank you!

    Report Comment

  • 4
    Paula Hillsden wrote on 3rd Jun 2009

    Never mind the politics, and forget evening classes for languages, how about compulsory foreign language classes from age 4? In our current education system many children do not attempt another language until secondary school, when it is far too late for many to pick up fluently. Our European counterparts are taught other languages (including English) from a very early age, when language ability is still forming - another reason why a higher percentage of people in mainland Europe speak better English than many of our natives.

    Report Comment

  • 5
    Alex R wrote on 4th Jun 2009

    I am with you on that Paula, I have a French Family friend who could speak 3 foreign languages fluently by the time he was 11, he is now a lecturer at a French College and can speak at least 7 languages fluently + some others vaguely that I know off, all because he learnt at an early age and last time I saw he in England people did not know he was foreign.  Unfortunately languages are not my strong point (I even have trouble with my own).

    Report Comment

  • 6
    Educationist wrote on 5th Jun 2009

    "Never mind the politics, and forget evening classes for languages, how about compulsory foreign language classes from age 4?" Well - foreign languages are now to be taught in primary school for the first time. Will that be welcomed by splenetic commenters? Probably not.

    Report Comment

Post a comment

Search this blog

February 2010
M
T
W
T
F
S
S
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28