SDN and NFV: Are they the same?

Anuradha Udunuwara MBCS examines the acronyms SDN and NFV, explains what they do and the differences between the two.

As the world progresses with unprecedented changes happening all around us, new terms/buzzwords (or abbreviations) are frequently introduced. Two such terms are SDN (or software defined networking) and NFV (or network functions virtualisation), widely used within telecom, cloud and enterprise environments. Even if you are from a different field than ICT (Information and communications technology), chances are that you have heard about these terms. One of the confusions specifically associated with SDN and NFV is whether they are the same? The short answer is ‘no’. Anyway, let’s look at little closer at SDN and NFV to beter understand them.

While the proper definition of NFV is available at ETSI NFV ISG (European Telecommunications Standards Institute NFV Industry Specification Group) whitepaper, the simple meaning is essentially about separating hardware from associated software in different network devices/elements. This allows for the running of different network functions (like Firewall, load balance, NAT, etc.) on cheap COTS (Commercial off-the-shelf) hardware, like switches and servers.

Going on the same viewpoint of separation, while the proper definition of SDN is available at ONF (open networking Foundation), SDN is about separating control plane from the forwarding (data) plane in a network element (ex: - router, switch, optical gear, etc.). This allows multiple forwarding planes to be controlled by a logically centralized controller or NOS (network operating system) as opposed to a single control plane (ex: - card in a router for example) and to control a single forwarding plane (ex:- line cards and backplane) in a traditional network element (ex:- internet protocol router).

NFV creates VNFs (virtual network functions) instead of traditional PNFs (physical network functions). For example, a traditional hardware firewall (PNF) vs. virtual firewall (VNF). You need connectivity between PNFs (traditionally) or VNFs or a mix of VNFs and PNFs (in a hybrid environment) to realise an end-to-end service. This connectivity can be provided by a SDN (within a data centre or between data centres). If you want to relate SDN and NFV to the ISO/OSI (International standards organisation/Open systems interconnection) stack, you can think of it as bottom three layers (layer 1 to layer 3) mapped to SDN and the top four layers (layer 4 to layer 7) mapped to NFV.

Both SDN and NFV can be implemented mutually exclusive to each other. However, having them together will give better benefits to telcos (or enterprises or cloud providers) and that is why you always see SDN and NFV referred together (SDN/NFV).

If you take the broad term ‘softwarisation’, which includes SDN, NFV and cloud, it is all about different abstractions;

  • NFV -> Communications abstraction
  • SDN -> Network abstraction
  • Cloud -> Compute abstraction 

The comparison below further explains the differences between SDN and NFV.

Parameter NFV SDN
Type of abstraction Communications Network
Key term in the abbreviation NF virtualization SD Networking
Architecture for Network Elements Network
VNF relevance Defines VNFs Provides connectivity between VNFs
Key focus Services
Resources (specially network)
Optimizes Network Functions Network
Defined by ETSI as a requirement ONF as a standard
 

About this blog

This blog is brought to you by the members of the BCS Internet Specialist Group and allows you to harness their skills, expertise and knowledge. The internet is ubiquitous and has a major impact on our daily lives, at work, at home on the move. The associated risks and security concerns are real, but the magic and advantages of the internet are significant.

See all posts by Internet Specialist Group
December 2018
M
T
W
T
F
S
S
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31

Search this blog